Enhancing statistical learning through mixed reality museum experiences
Academic Research, Interaction Design, Prototyping
Award Winner at the 2022 NC State University
Graduate Research Symposium
The Master of Graphic Design degree culminates in a yearlong design research project. This project began with a long-term interest in how we learn and delight in science and mathematics. I think many of the best and most engaging ways for students to engage with science and mathematics remain largely undervalued and underexplored.
Statistical literacy, or the ability to understand and interpret data, has become increasingly important to navigating our data-driven society. While many efforts have focused on improving formal learning experiences in statistics, research points towards informal learning outside of the classroom as a crucial component of the general public’s understanding of science and mathematics. This presents a rich opportunity to enhance statistical learning for young students through the design of compelling informal learning experiences.
Drawing from the framework for statistics and data science education from the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, this investigation explores the ways in which a mixed reality museum experience can engage middle school-age learners with the stages of the statistical problem-solving process.
The project began with a full literature review, including relevant theories and precedents to flesh out the problem space. Many problems with statistical numeracy are attributed to “unfavorable methods” of teaching statistics in formal learning environments. The museum is uniquely situated to provide informal learning experiences that are experiment-driven, fluid, and playful.
The design portion of the project consists of four studies, which explore four different stages of the statistical investigative process. Each study from one through three forms one component of the designed museum experience; Study Four will draw from the previous studies to form a complete experience prototype.
Exploring data collection in a projection mapped environment
Study One explores how a projection mapped floor can encourage visitors to consider potential statistical variation in the context of water quality in a river system.
Representational styles were a key component of this study. An abstract, waving grid indicates areas within the projected environment with a greater or lesser degree of deviation from the average. As the visitor moves through and interacts with the environment, bright yellow components are used to denote elements for the learner to make use of, experiment with, or to otherwise indicate points of relevance.
Visitors are also provided with a variety of ways to engage with the environment that vary in length and in degree of experimentation. The visitor can passively walk through and observe a magnified view of the water below, or can take a more active approach in collecting samples or manipulating variables physically to see their impact on the scene in real time.
Three-dimensional icons of factors impacting water quality invite visitors to move, touch, and act upon their surroundings in a way not typically possible.
Study Two, Part One:
Diving into data with interactive touch tables
Study Two explores the next phase of the experience, in which a visitor takes a water quality sample away from the floor area to further explore the data. This stage of the statistical investigative process involves understanding and explaining sources of variability in the data. What variables contributed to the distribution seen in the data collected, and in what ways?
The Investigation Station design invites a visitor to place a collected sample on the table. A component of the sample then appears in a microscope view to the left, and a life-sized view of the area the sample was collected from is viewable to the right. The visitor can switch between each of four water quality components in the sample viewer by moving a selection disc.
The design guides a learner from the specifics of their own sample outwards to the context. This contextualization is crucial to understanding statistical investigations and prompts the visitor to dig deeply and think critically about a data point or a data set while allowing their own curiosity to guide their explorations.
Study Two, Part Two:
Immersion in data with interactive walls
The Distribution Aquarium invites learners to walk along a distribution visual to add and explore a sample. The visitor can see a spectrum of water quality represented along the wall, from the poorest water quality within the river system at the left to the best at the right.
One aim of this study was to explore how data might be visualized differently from traditional statistical representations, such as distribution curves or graphs.
In this design, the user is directed by indicators on the floor which direction they must travel along the wall to place their sample. The visitor is challenged to consider not only the data distribution, but the spectrum of the samples that compose and contextualize the data.
The data itself is not shown in a typical distribution, as this example water quality data is not composed of single, numerically quantifiable variables. Instead, each sample appears as a circle within the correct water quality category, from "Very Poor" to "Very High" water quality.
Over time, these samples fade, allowing visitors to view shifts in the average and the spread as they occur. This diagram shows the effect as a theoretical average shifts from "left" to "right".
The visitor can dive in to a particular data point through touch interactions with the wall. Within the sample circles, they can see magnified views of a select number of water quality indicators, and discover more in-depth information about how each indicator contributes to the sample's overall placement along the spectrum of water quality.
The goal of the wall is not to provide for robust statistical investigations. To the contrary — the goal of the wall is to provide an impression that data can tell a story. The distribution of samples on the wall, paired with the lively aquarium visuals, give the visitor a dynamic portrait of the overall health of the river system. The ability to dig into a sample provides the visitor with the general understanding that the variables that contribute to overall metrics can be deep and complex, always warranting careful exploration.
This project is ongoing. Check back soon for additional work.